Fascism vs Communism

Introduction

Communism and fascism are two distinct ideologies that have shaped the course of the 20th century and continue to impact the world today. Both systems represent radical alternatives to liberal democracy and capitalism, but they differ significantly in their fundamental principles, economic structures, and political organizations.

This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison between communism and fascism, highlighting the key differences and similarities between these two ideologies.

By examining their historical backgrounds, core tenets, and real-world implementations, we hope to foster a better understanding of these influential yet often misunderstood systems, and contribute to the ongoing discourse surrounding their role in shaping modern societies.

Summary of Comparisons

1. Historical Background

Origins of Communism

Communism traces its roots to the works of German philosophers Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, most notably their 1848 publication, “The Communist Manifesto.” Marx and Engels criticized the inequalities and injustices of capitalist societies, advocating for a classless society where the means of production are owned collectively.

Throughout the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the communist movement gained momentum, culminating in the 1917 Russian Revolution led by Vladimir Lenin and the Bolshevik Party. The establishment of the Soviet Union marked the beginning of the first large-scale experiment in implementing communism as a political and economic system.

Origins of Fascism

Fascism emerged in the early 20th century as a response to the perceived failures of liberal democracy and the threat of communism. It originated in Italy, where Benito Mussolini founded the National Fascist Party in 1919 and later seized power in 1922. Fascism is characterized by strong nationalism, authoritarianism, and an emphasis on ethnic or racial purity.

It was further developed in Germany by Adolf Hitler and the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (Nazi Party), which came to power in 1933. The rise of fascism in Europe during the 1930s and 1940s led to a period of intense conflict, culminating in World War II and the Holocaust.

Both communism and fascism emerged as radical alternatives to the prevailing systems of their time, seeking to address societal issues and reshape the world according to their respective visions. However, as we will see in the following sections, their approaches to achieving these goals differ significantly.

2.Fundamental Principles

Key Tenets of Communism

1. Classless society: Communism aims to create a society without distinct social classes, where wealth and resources are distributed according to individual needs. This principle seeks to eliminate the exploitation and inequality inherent in capitalist systems.
2. Collective ownership of the means of production: Communism advocates for the collective ownership and control of the means of production, such as factories, farms, and natural resources. This is intended to prevent private accumulation of wealth and ensure fair distribution of resources.
3. Abolition of private property: In a communist society, private property is replaced by communal ownership, with the goal of eliminating economic disparities and fostering a sense of shared responsibility and cooperation among citizens.
4. Central planning: A central authority in a communist state is responsible for planning and directing the economy, determining the production and distribution of goods and services to meet the needs of society.
5. Internationalism: Communism emphasizes the importance of international solidarity among the working class, transcending national boundaries and promoting global cooperation to achieve common goals.

Key Tenets of Fascism

1. Authoritarianism: Fascism promotes a strong, centralized government led by a single leader or small group, often referred to as a dictator or ruling party. This concentration of power is intended to ensure order, stability, and control over society.
2. Nationalism: Fascism is characterized by an extreme emphasis on national identity and pride. It seeks to unify the nation under a shared culture, history, and set of values, often with an exclusionary approach to outsiders or minority groups.
3. Militarism: Fascist states tend to prioritize military strength and expansion, promoting the idea that conflict and war are necessary for national growth and development.
4. Suppression of dissent: Fascism values conformity and loyalty to the state above individual freedoms, often resulting in the suppression of dissent, censorship, and persecution of political opponents.
5. Social Darwinism: Fascism is influenced by the concept of social Darwinism, which posits that the strong should dominate the weak in society. This belief can manifest in the form of racism, eugenics, and the pursuit of an idealized “master race.”

While both communism and fascism seek to create a new societal order, their fundamental principles reveal stark differences in their approaches and underlying philosophies. Communism focuses on the collective ownership and classless society, whereas fascism emphasizes authoritarianism, nationalism, and social Darwinism.

3. Economic Systems

Economic Structure of a Communist Society

1. Central planning: In a communist economy, a central authority or government is responsible for planning and directing the production and distribution of goods and services. This central planning aims to allocate resources efficiently and in accordance with the needs of society.
2. Public ownership: The means of production, such as factories, farms, and natural resources, are owned and controlled by the state. This eliminates private ownership and profit motives, seeking to ensure that the benefits of production are shared equally among the population.
3. Price controls: The government regulates prices for goods and services in a communist economy, preventing market forces from determining costs. This is intended to maintain stability and ensure basic necessities are affordable for all citizens.
4. Elimination of unemployment: Full employment is a goal of communist economies, as the state is responsible for providing jobs and ensuring that everyone contributes to the collective well-being of society.
5. No competition: In a communist system, there is no competition between businesses or industries, as the state controls all aspects of production and distribution. The emphasis is on cooperation and meeting societal needs rather than pursuing individual profit.

Economic Structure of a Fascist Society

1. State-controlled capitalism: Fascist economies maintain elements of capitalism, such as private ownership and market competition. However, the state exercises significant control over businesses and industries, often dictating policies and directing economic activities to serve national interests.
2. Corporatism: Fascist societies promote a system of corporatism, in which the government, businesses, and labor organizations collaborate to manage the economy. This approach aims to balance the interests of different stakeholders while maintaining strong state control.
3. National self-sufficiency: Fascist economies often prioritize achieving national self-sufficiency, minimizing reliance on imports and foreign resources. This approach can lead to a focus on domestic production and protectionist trade policies.
4. Military-industrial complex: Fascist states typically emphasize the importance of a strong military and may invest heavily in defense industries. This prioritization of military spending can drive economic growth and foster technological advancements.
5. Limited social welfare: While fascist societies may provide some social welfare programs, they generally place less emphasis on wealth redistribution and social safety nets compared to communist societies. Fascist governments often prioritize national strength and unity over addressing economic inequality.

In summary, communist economies are characterized by central planning, public ownership, and the elimination of competition, while fascist economies maintain elements of capitalism with strong state control, corporatism, and a focus on national self-sufficiency and militarism.

4. Political Systems

Political Organization in a Communist State

1. One-party system: Communist states typically operate under a one-party system, where the communist party holds a monopoly on political power. This approach is intended to ensure ideological unity and prevent the emergence of competing factions.
2. Dictatorship of the proletariat: According to Marxist theory, a communist state is meant to be governed by the working class, or the “proletariat,” to dismantle the capitalist system and transition to a classless society. In practice, however, many communist states have been characterized by centralized power structures and authoritarian rule.
3. Suppression of dissent: In a communist state, opposing views and political dissent are often suppressed to maintain ideological unity and control over the populace. This can include censorship, propaganda, and persecution of political opponents.
4. Internationalism: Communist states often emphasize international solidarity and cooperation among the working class, aiming to support communist movements and revolutions in other countries.

Political Organization in a Fascist State

1. Authoritarian rule: Fascist states are characterized by a strong, centralized government led by a single leader or a small group, often referred to as a dictator or ruling party. This concentration of power is intended to ensure order, stability, and control over society.
2. Nationalism: Fascist governments prioritize national identity and pride, often using propaganda and indoctrination to promote a shared culture, history, and set of values among citizens. This emphasis on nationalism can result in exclusionary policies and discrimination against minority groups or outsiders.
3. Suppression of dissent: Like communist states, fascist governments often suppress dissent and opposition to maintain control and foster national unity. This can include strict censorship, propaganda, and persecution of political opponents.
4. Militarism: Fascist states typically prioritize military strength and expansion, often glorifying war and conflict as necessary for national growth and development. This can lead to aggressive foreign policies and a focus on maintaining a powerful military apparatus.

While both communist and fascist political systems are characterized by centralized power and suppression of dissent, they differ significantly in their underlying ideologies and priorities. Communist states emphasize class struggle and the eventual creation of a classless society, while fascist states prioritize national unity, strength, and the pursuit of an idealized nation.

5. Role of the Individual and Society

Individual Rights and Responsibilities in Communism

1. Collective focus: In a communist society, the emphasis is on the collective well-being rather than individual pursuits. Citizens are expected to contribute to the common good, working together to achieve shared goals and ensure that resources are distributed fairly.
2. Equality: Communism aims to eliminate social and economic inequalities by abolishing class distinctions and providing equal access to resources and opportunities. Individual achievements and wealth accumulation are not prioritized, as the focus is on ensuring a baseline standard of living for all citizens.
3. Limited personal freedom: Personal freedoms, such as freedom of speech, religion, and assembly, may be restricted in a communist state to maintain ideological unity and social order. The state often plays a significant role in shaping individual beliefs and behaviors through propaganda and education.
4. State-provided services: In a communist society, the state is responsible for providing essential services, such as healthcare, education, and housing, to ensure that all citizens have access to these basic necessities.

Individual Rights and Responsibilities in Fascism

1. Loyalty to the state: In a fascist society, loyalty to the state and its leader is paramount. Individuals are expected to prioritize the needs of the nation above their own and to conform to the state’s vision of an ideal citizen.
2. Hierarchical society: Fascism often promotes a hierarchical social structure based on the belief in the inherent superiority of certain groups. Individual rights and opportunities may be determined by one’s position within this hierarchy, with members of the dominant group enjoying privileges and benefits.
3. Suppression of individualism: Fascist governments often suppress individualism and dissent, emphasizing the importance of conformity and loyalty to the state. Personal freedoms, such as freedom of speech and assembly, may be restricted to maintain social order and national unity.
4. Limited social welfare: While fascist states may provide some social welfare programs, they generally place less emphasis on wealth redistribution and social safety nets compared to communist societies. Individual success and achievement may be more highly valued, with a focus on strengthening the nation as a whole.

In summary, the role of the individual and society in communism and fascism is shaped by their respective ideologies and priorities. Communism emphasizes collective well-being, equality, and state-provided services, while fascism prioritizes loyalty to the state, a hierarchical social structure, and national unity and strength. Both systems often impose restrictions on personal freedoms to maintain ideological unity and control over the populace.

6. Real-World Examples

Communist States

1. Soviet Union (1922-1991): The Soviet Union was the first country to implement a communist system based on the theories of Marx and Lenin. The state controlled all aspects of the economy and suppressed political dissent. While the Soviet Union initially experienced rapid industrialization and economic growth, it eventually collapsed due to a combination of economic stagnation, political unrest, and external pressures.
2. People’s Republic of China: Established in 1949, the People’s Republic of China adopted a communist system under the leadership of Mao Zedong. Although China has since undergone significant economic reforms, it remains a one-party communist state. The Chinese government continues to maintain strict control over the economy, the media, and political dissent.
3. Cuba: Cuba became a communist state in 1959 after the Cuban Revolution led by Fidel Castro. The Cuban government nationalized industries, implemented central planning, and pursued policies of wealth redistribution. Despite facing economic challenges and external pressures, Cuba remains one of the few remaining communist states today.

Fascist States

1. Italy (1922-1943): Italy is often considered the birthplace of fascism, with Benito Mussolini establishing a fascist regime in the 1920s. The Italian fascist state promoted nationalism, militarism, and strict control over political dissent. Italy’s alliance with Nazi Germany during World War II ultimately led to the downfall of Mussolini’s regime.
2. Nazi Germany (1933-1945): Adolf Hitler’s National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP) implemented a fascist regime in Germany. The Nazis pursued aggressive expansionist policies, promoted an extreme form of nationalism and racial superiority, and engaged in widespread persecution of political opponents, minority groups, and others deemed “undesirable.” The defeat of Nazi Germany in World War II marked the end of the regime.
3. Spain (1939-1975): Spain experienced a fascist regime under General Francisco Franco, who came to power after the Spanish Civil War. Franco’s regime emphasized Spanish nationalism, conservatism, and strict control over political dissent. After Franco’s death in 1975, Spain transitioned to a democratic system.

These real-world examples of communism and fascism illustrate the varying degrees to which these ideologies have been implemented and their historical impacts. While both systems have led to instances of authoritarian rule, economic control, and suppression of dissent, they differ in their underlying principles and priorities, as demonstrated by the unique characteristics of each example.

7.Criticisms and Challenges

Criticisms of Communism

1. Lack of incentives: Critics argue that communism’s emphasis on equal distribution of resources and the absence of private ownership can lead to a lack of incentives for individuals to work hard or innovate, as personal achievements and wealth accumulation are not prioritized.
2. Inefficiencies and economic stagnation: Central planning in communist economies has often been criticized for creating inefficiencies and stifling innovation, as the state’s control over resources and decision-making can lead to misallocations, bureaucracy, and a lack of competition.
3. Suppression of freedoms: Communist states are often criticized for their suppression of individual freedoms, such as freedom of speech, assembly, and religion. The state’s control over media, education, and political dissent can result in an atmosphere of fear and repression.
4. Authoritarian rule: Many communist states have been characterized by authoritarian rule and abuses of power, as the one-party system and concentration of political authority can enable corruption and limit checks on government actions.

Criticisms of Fascism

1. Suppression of individualism and dissent: Fascist states often suppress individualism and dissenting views, limiting personal freedoms and promoting conformity to the state’s ideals. This can create an environment in which diversity of thought and open debate are stifled.
2. Discrimination and persecution: Fascist regimes frequently promote a hierarchy based on perceived superiority, which can lead to discrimination and persecution of minority groups and those deemed “undesirable” by the state. This exclusionary approach can foster division, hatred, and violence within society.
3. Aggressive militarism: Fascist states often prioritize military strength and expansion, which can result in aggressive foreign policies and a focus on maintaining a powerful military apparatus. This militaristic approach can lead to armed conflicts and undermine international peace and cooperation.
4. Authoritarian rule: Like communist states, fascist governments are often characterized by authoritarian rule and abuses of power. The concentration of political authority in the hands of a single leader or ruling party can enable corruption and limit checks on government actions.

Both communism and fascism have faced significant criticisms and challenges due to their perceived shortcomings and historical consequences. While the two systems differ in their underlying ideologies and priorities, they share some common challenges, including the potential for authoritarian rule, suppression of individual freedoms, and negative social and economic impacts.

Conclusion

Communism and fascism, as two distinct ideologies and political systems, have had significant impacts on the course of modern history. While both systems share certain characteristics, such as authoritarian rule and the suppression of dissent, they differ fundamentally in their core principles and priorities.

Communism emphasizes the importance of collective well-being, wealth redistribution, and the eventual creation of a classless society, while fascism prioritizes national unity, strength, and the pursuit of an idealized nation.

By examining the historical background, fundamental principles, economic and political structures, role of the individual and society, real-world examples, and criticisms and challenges of both systems, we can gain a better understanding of the distinctions between communism and fascism.

This understanding can help inform ongoing debates about the merits and drawbacks of various political and economic systems and the ways in which they shape the societies in which they are implemented.

FAQs

About Paul

Paul Boyce is an economics editor with over 10 years experience in the industry. Currently working as a consultant within the financial services sector, Paul is the CEO and chief editor of BoyceWire. He has written publications for FEE, the Mises Institute, and many others.

Further Reading

Bill of Sale - A bill of sale is a legal document that serves as proof of the transfer of ownership of an item…

Market Equilibrium: What it is & Graph - Market equilibrium occurs when demand and supply meet.

Producer Surplus: Definition, Formula & How to Calculate - The producer surplus is the difference between what the producer sells its goods for and the minimum price it would…